Summary
At an extraordinary consistory of cardinals, Bishop Emir Joseph Zen Ze-Kiun criticized Pope Francis for implementing synodality in a manner he found manipulative and insulting. During the January 7-8 meeting, Zen delivered his critique, emphasizing that the process was an “ironclad manipulation” and “insult to the dignity of the bishops.” He argued that Pope Francis bypassed the College of Bishops while insisting on its appropriateness for understanding hierarchical ministry. Zen also criticized the use of the Holy Spirit in synodal discussions, stating they were “ridiculous and almost blasphemous,” adding inconsistencies within the Synod’s final document regarding unity of teaching and practice. He questioned whether the bishops could discern properly from the Holy Spirit’s inspiration and wondered if differing interpretations would lead to Church division. Zen also disputed Pope Francis’ use of synodality, noting that he had transformed it into a system where non-bishops have formal roles. The Vatican press office made no mention of Zen’s criticism during the meeting.
Key Topics
Cardinal Zen Ze-Kiun, Synodality, Holy Spirit
