Summary
In 2023, Bishop Paprocki condemned Cardinal McElroy’s controversial articles on Catholic moral theology in First Things. Despite his reluctance to name names, Bishop Paprocki suggested other European cardinals were also involved. Critics argue that today’s bishops lack the courage and manly faith of saints like those mentioned by Pope Leo. The article highlights examples such as Archbishop Cordileone, who excommunicated child-abuse perpetrators with support from over sixteen bishops; and Bishop Strickland of Tyler, Texas, who was sacked for his stance against heresy. The piece advocates for a charitable anathema, drawing parallels to previous papal calls but noting the Vatican’s reluctance in implementing such measures since 1965. One example given is Notre Dame’s defiance of church teachings during the 1960s, leading to widespread American Catholicism embracing heretical views. The bishops are viewed as either unwilling or ineffective in defending orthodox doctrines against dissenting voices within their ranks.
Key Topics
Bishops, Pope Leo, anathema
